Poem Analysis - Supposing That I Should Have The Courage

Initial Impression and Tone

Stephen Crane's poem Supposing That I Should Have The Courage presents a contemplative and somewhat defiant tone. The speaker considers the idea of embracing a virtuous act, but ultimately rejects it, questioning the value of such an action. The poem shifts from a moment of potential bravery to a resolute dismissal, reflecting the speaker's internal struggle and skepticism. The language is straightforward yet evocative, using vivid imagery to convey the speaker's thoughts and emotions.

Themes of Virtue and Skepticism

The poem explores the theme of virtue, particularly the idea of making a noble or self-sacrificing act. The red sword of virtue symbolizes this noble act, which the speaker initially considers but ultimately rejects. The speaker's skepticism is evident in the question What can you offer me?, suggesting a deep-seated doubt about the rewards or benefits of virtuous actions. This skepticism is further emphasized in the final lines, where the speaker dismisses the idea of virtue altogether, indicating a profound disillusionment with traditional notions of heroism or sacrifice.

Imagery of Nature and Decay

The poem uses vivid imagery of nature to contrast the ideas of virtue and decay. The red sword of virtue is juxtaposed with the weeds of the ground, suggesting that even the most noble acts can lead to decay and oblivion. The gardened castle and flowery kingdom are offered as potential rewards for virtuous actions, but these images are tinged with a sense of artificiality and transience. The speaker's rejection of these rewards underscores the theme of skepticism, as the speaker seems to prefer the natural, albeit sinful, state over the artificial rewards of virtue.

Symbolism of the Red Sword

The red sword of virtue is a central symbol in the poem, representing the idea of a noble or self-sacrificing act. The color red is often associated with passion, danger, and bloodshed, adding layers of meaning to the symbol. The sword's redness could signify the pain or sacrifice involved in virtuous actions, or it could represent the passion and intensity of the speaker's internal struggle. The speaker's ultimate rejection of the sword suggests a complex relationship with the idea of virtue, one that is tinged with both admiration and skepticism. The sword's vivid imagery also contributes to the poem's overall tone of contemplative defiance, as the speaker grapples with the idea of embracing or rejecting virtue.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Supposing That I Should Have The Courage is a poem that explores the themes of virtue, skepticism, and the natural cycle of life and decay. Through vivid imagery and powerful symbolism, Crane presents a speaker who is deeply conflicted about the value of virtuous actions. The poem's contemplative and defiant tone reflects the speaker's internal struggle, ultimately leading to a rejection of traditional notions of heroism or sacrifice. The poem's significance lies in its exploration of the complexities of human nature and the enduring questions it raises about the value of virtue in a world marked by decay and transience.