Poem Analysis - Blacklisted

Initial Impression and Tone

Carl Sandburg's poem Blacklisted presents a reflective and somewhat defiant tone, exploring the speaker's contemplation on the significance of personal identity and societal expectations. The poem begins with a questioning stance, challenging the importance of a name and the expectations tied to it. The mood shifts from introspective to assertive, as the speaker asserts their desire to live and work, regardless of societal or divine judgment. The straightforward language and direct questions create an engaging and thought-provoking atmosphere.

Themes of Identity and Self-Determination

The primary theme of Blacklisted is the exploration of personal identity and the power of self-determination. The speaker questions the value of a name, suggesting that it is merely a cheap thing given by parents and holds little intrinsic value. This questioning reflects a desire to break free from societal constraints and define oneself on one's own terms. The repetition of the phrase why does God Almighty or anybody else care emphasizes the speaker's defiance against external judgments and expectations. The theme of self-determination is further highlighted by the speaker's assertion that a job is a job and I want to live, indicating a focus on practical survival and personal agency.

The Role of Work and Survival

Another significant theme is the role of work and survival in shaping one's identity. The speaker's emphasis on the need to live and work suggests that these practical aspects of life are more important than societal or divine approval. The phrase a job is a job and I want to live underscores the speaker's prioritization of survival and self-sufficiency over conforming to societal norms. This theme is reinforced by the speaker's willingness to take a new name to go by, indicating a willingness to adapt and change in order to meet practical needs.

Symbolism of the Name

The name serves as a central symbol in the poem, representing both personal identity and societal expectations. The speaker's questioning of the value of a name suggests a desire to break free from the constraints of societal norms and define oneself on one's own terms. The phrase a cheap thing all fathers and mothers leave each child further emphasizes the idea that a name is merely a label imposed by others, rather than a true reflection of one's identity. The speaker's willingness to take a new name to go by indicates a desire for self-determination and the ability to adapt and change in order to meet practical needs.

Conclusion and Final Insight

In conclusion, Carl Sandburg's Blacklisted is a powerful exploration of personal identity, self-determination, and the role of work and survival in shaping one's life. Through the use of direct questions and straightforward language, the poem challenges societal expectations and emphasizes the importance of practical survival and personal agency. The symbolism of the name serves as a central theme, representing both personal identity and societal constraints. The poem ultimately offers a defiant assertion of the speaker's right to define themselves on their own terms, regardless of external judgments or expectations. This poem invites readers to consider the true value of personal identity and the power of self-determination in the face of societal and divine expectations.