Poem Analysis - They All Want To Play Hamlet

Initial Impressions and Tone

Carl Sandburg's They All Want To Play Hamlet presents a reflective and somewhat melancholic tone, exploring the allure of tragedy and the desire for dramatic expression. The poem begins with a straightforward statement about the universal appeal of playing Hamlet, then delves into the specific experiences and emotions that Hamlet embodies. The mood shifts from a general observation to a more introspective examination of why actors are drawn to this particular role. The poem's form, with its repetitive phrases and varied line lengths, supports the idea of a recurring, almost obsessive, desire to engage with Hamlet's tragic story.

Themes of Tragedy and Acting

The poem primarily explores the themes of tragedy and the nature of acting. Sandburg highlights the tragic elements of Hamlet's life, such as the death of his father, the betrayal by his mother, and the loss of Ophelia. These experiences are contrasted with the actors' lack of direct, personal tragedy, suggesting that the appeal of Hamlet lies in the opportunity to experience and express profound sadness vicariously. The theme of acting is central, as Sandburg repeatedly emphasizes the performative aspect of wanting to play Hamlet. The actors know they are acting, yet they are drawn to the role because it allows them to engage with deep emotions and wise, beautiful words.

Themes of Emotional Connection

Another significant theme is the emotional connection that actors seek through their roles. The poem suggests that actors are drawn to Hamlet because it resonates with their own sadness and desire for expression. The phrase "This is something that calls and calls to their blood" emphasizes the deep, almost primal, attraction to the role. The actors' desire to stand by an open grave with a joker's skull and recite wise, beautiful words indicates a longing for a meaningful emotional experience, even if it is simulated.

Symbols and Imagery

The poem is rich with vivid imagery and symbols that enhance its themes. The "joker's skull" and the "open grave" are powerful symbols of mortality and tragedy, representing the dark and profound aspects of Hamlet's story. The "flowers slung by a dancing girl" and the "singing golden spiders" add a layer of beauty and complexity, suggesting that even in tragedy, there is a certain elegance and allure. The "inkfish" is an intriguing image that could symbolize the elusive and mysterious nature of Shakespeare's writing, or the way actors try to capture the essence of a character. The ambiguity of this symbol invites readers to consider their own interpretations of what it might represent.

Conclusion

In conclusion, They All Want To Play Hamlet by Carl Sandburg delves into the universal appeal of tragedy and the emotional depth that actors seek in their roles. Through vivid imagery and recurring symbols, Sandburg explores the themes of tragedy, acting, and emotional connection. The poem suggests that the desire to play Hamlet is rooted in a deep, almost primal, attraction to the role's profound sadness and the opportunity to express wise, beautiful words. Ultimately, the poem offers insight into the human longing for meaningful emotional experiences, even if they are simulated through the art of acting.