Poem Analysis - What A Writer

A Tribute to Originality

Charles Bukowski's "What A Writer" is a concise and admiring nod to the innovative spirit of e.e. cummings. The poem carries a tone of appreciation, almost reverence, for Cummings's groundbreaking approach to poetry. It contrasts Cummings's genuine originality with the often-unsuccessful attempts of imitators, highlighting the unique nature of true artistic genius. The poem's mood shifts subtly from admiration to a slightly cynical observation about the nature of imitation, before returning to a celebration of individual brilliance.

The Burden of Antiquated Forms

Bukowski's poem speaks to a weariness with traditional poetic forms. He uses the phrase "sanctity of the word" to describe the rigid expectations that Cummings defied. This suggests that Bukowski saw Cummings as a liberating force, someone who "cleaved through the muck" of outdated conventions. This "muck" represents the tired, uninspired poetry that Bukowski felt stifled genuine expression. The line, "How we languished in the antiquated, weary ways," conveys the feeling of being trapped by the past, highlighting the need for artistic revolution.

The Perils of Imitation

A central theme of the poem is the distinction between originality and imitation. Bukowski acknowledges that Cummings's success inevitably led to a wave of imitators. However, he dismisses these attempts as mere "mimicking," emphasizing that true artistry cannot be replicated. The list of "Keats, Shelley, Swinburne, Byron, and the like" serves as a broader reminder that even the greatest poets have been subject to imitation, but their originality remains unsurpassed. This reinforces the idea that authenticity is paramount in art.

Symbolic Uniqueness: Sun and Moon

The poem utilizes potent symbolism to underscore the uniqueness of e.e. cummings. Bukowski writes, "One sun. One moon." These celestial bodies serve as powerful metaphors for originality and irreplaceability. Just as there is only one sun and one moon, there can only be one e.e. cummings. This imagery emphasizes the singular nature of his talent and suggests that some artistic voices are simply unmatched. The simplicity of these images amplifies their impact, conveying the idea of inherent and undeniable uniqueness.

A Legacy of Breaking Boundaries

In conclusion, "What A Writer" is more than just a tribute to e.e. cummings; it's a statement about the importance of originality and the futility of mere imitation. Bukowski celebrates Cummings's courage to break free from convention and create something truly unique. The poem serves as a reminder that while influence is inevitable, true artistic greatness lies in forging one's own path and resisting the urge to simply copy what has come before. Ultimately, Bukowski suggests that the most lasting impact a writer can have is to inspire others to find their own authentic voice, rather than echoing the voices of the past.