Poem Analysis - Wont You
A Plea Born of Rejection
Shel Silverstein's "Won't You?" is a short, deceptively simple poem that masks a core of vulnerability with a touch of humor. The tone begins with seemingly lighthearted observations about unavailable women, but quickly transitions to a plea for companionship. This quick shift from objective statement to personal request creates a poignant, almost desperate undercurrent. The poem's brevity enhances its impact, leaving the reader to ponder the sincerity and potential underlying sadness of the speaker's proposition.
The Desperate Search for Connection
The central theme of "Won't You?" is undoubtedly the desire for connection and the avoidance of isolation, specifically on Valentine's Day. The poem catalogs a series of romantic rejections, one after another. "Barbara's eyes are blue as azure, But she is in love with Freddy," sets the stage immediately, highlighting the speaker's inability to attain the affection of the women he desires. The repetition of this pattern – Karen is taken, Jane is unavailable, Carol and May actively dislike him, Abigail rejects him, and Nancy is geographically distant – emphasizes the speaker's repeated failures in love. This string of rejections highlights a profound sense of loneliness and the urgent need to find someone, *anyone*, to share Valentine's Day with. The poem’s concise form only magnifies the feeling of rejection and highlights the simple desperation to not be alone.
The Color Blue and Romantic Obstacles
The poem utilizes only one clear color image, “Barbara’s eyes are blue as azure”. The choice of blue, often associated with tranquility and depth, is ironic considering the context. While her eyes are described beautifully, the color serves only to emphasize the speaker's unattainable desire. The beauty is there, but it’s out of reach. More broadly, the poem can be seen as using the names themselves as symbols. Each name represents a roadblock, an obstacle preventing the speaker from finding love. Each name represents something that does not want him back. The list of names and reasons for unavailability grows increasingly absurd, highlighting the speaker's plight. The names create a quick and somewhat comedic rhythm before the last line breaks the pattern and becomes a direct and poignant question.
A Questionable Valentine's Proposition
The poem ends with a direct question: "Won't you be my Valentine?" This question, seemingly simple, carries a significant weight. The speaker's willingness to ask this question after listing so many rejections suggests a level of desperation. The question prompts a unique interpretation: Is this a genuine offer of romance, or simply a plea to avoid being alone on a holiday centered around love? Is the speaker lowering his standards in the face of repeated disappointment? The lack of any description of the addressee makes the question more ambiguous, suggesting that the speaker might be addressing anyone who is willing to accept his offer.
A Poignant Plea for Companionship
In conclusion, "Won't You?" is a surprisingly affecting poem that explores themes of loneliness, rejection, and the yearning for connection. Silverstein masterfully uses simple language and a concise form to create a portrait of a person facing repeated romantic disappointment. The final question, "Won't you be my Valentine?" encapsulates the poem's central theme: the desire to avoid isolation and to find some form of companionship, even if it's born out of desperation. The poem's true significance lies in its ability to evoke empathy for the speaker and to make the reader consider the universal human need for love and acceptance, particularly on a day dedicated to celebrating it.
Feel free to be first to leave comment.