Poem Analysis - My Reward For Being Was This

A Humble Majesty: Introduction

Emily Dickinson's "My Reward for Being, was This" is a compact and somewhat defiant exploration of the speaker's unique understanding of value and reward. The poem initially expresses a sense of disappointment with earthly power and possessions. However, it shifts toward a declaration of a more profound, eternal reward that transcends worldly measures. The tone moves from a suggestion of loss to a confident assertion of spiritual or existential significance.

Rejecting Earthly Power

One dominant theme is the rejection of conventional power. Dickinson uses the imagery of royalty – "Admiralty," "Sceptre," "Realms," and "Thrones" – but diminishes their worth. The Admiralty is "less," the Sceptre is "penniless," and the Realms are "just Dross" (worthless refuse). This deliberately undermines the perceived value of these traditional symbols of authority and wealth. The poem suggests that these things lack genuine substance or meaning for the speaker. This theme highlights a preference for something beyond the material.

An Eternal Election

The poem also develops the theme of eternal validation or recognition. The lines "Dominions dowerless beside this Grace—Election Vote—The Ballots of Eternity, will show just that" point towards a reward system based on divine or existential election. The speaker suggests that there is a higher judgment where true value is assessed. This stands in contrast to the superficial values of earthly kingdoms. The "Election Vote" and "Ballots of Eternity" imply a lasting recognition of the speaker's worth, surpassing any worldly recognition. This theme portrays a belief in an ultimate justice or order.

The "Grace" of Existence

Furthermore, the poem touches upon the theme of intrinsic value of existence. The speaker's "Reward for Being" implies that simply existing is a form of merit, deserving of a unique "Grace." This "Grace" seems to be the ultimate reward. It overshadows even the most magnificent earthly kingdoms ("Dominions dowerless beside this Grace"). This theme suggests that existence itself is precious. It is valued independently of external achievements or possessions. Perhaps, the simple act of being is enough to warrant a significant, eternal reward. The "Grace" becomes a symbol for the profound value of the speaker's own identity and experience.

The Dowerless Dominion: Symbolism and Ambiguity

The phrase "Dominions dowerless" is a particularly compelling image. The word "dowerless" usually refers to a bride who brings no dowry to a marriage. In this context, it might suggest that the speaker's promised "Dominions" or spiritual inheritance are obtained without any requirement or payment on her part. This highlights the idea of inherent worthiness. This is as opposed to earned merit. It could also be interpreted as a comment on the transactional nature of societal expectations, contrasting it with a purely spiritual and unconditional acceptance. The ambiguity allows for a nuanced understanding of the "Grace" as both a gift and an inherent quality.

Final Insight: The Value of Being

In conclusion, "My Reward for Being, was This" is a powerful declaration of individual value. Dickinson contrasts earthly power with a deeper, more profound reward. She suggests that the simple act of existing holds intrinsic worth. The poem uses vivid imagery of royalty and elections to highlight the speaker's rejection of worldly values. It asserts a belief in an eternal validation based on "Grace." Ultimately, the poem's significance lies in its assertion that true reward resides not in external possessions but in the very essence of being.