Poem Analysis - We See Comparatively

Introduction: The Shifting Landscape of Perception

Emily Dickinson's "We See Comparatively" explores the fluctuating nature of perception and the humbling realization that what once seemed monumental can, with time and a shift in perspective, shrink to insignificance. The poem begins with a sense of awe at a seemingly insurmountable object, then transitions into a dismissive tone as that object diminishes in importance. Ultimately, it offers a compassionate perspective, suggesting that this deflation of ego may be a kindness. The poem’s overall mood is reflective, tinged with both wistfulness and acceptance.

The Diminishing Grandeur: A Theme of Perspective

One of the primary themes in "We See Comparatively" is the relativity of perception. The opening lines emphasize the initially overwhelming nature of "The Thing so towering high," something so immense that it could not be "grasp[ed]" without assistance. The phrase "Unaided Yesterday" points to a previous state of struggle and limited understanding. However, the second stanza introduces a dramatic shift. "This Morning's finer Verdict" suggests a new, more informed viewpoint. The result is a devaluation of the previously imposing object, reducing a "Cordillera" (mountain range) to a "Knoll" (small hill). The poem uses geographical imagery to illustrate this shift, representing the vastness of our initial perceptions being reduced to insignificant proportions with the passing of time and new understanding.

Kindness in Diminishment: Ego and Its Guardians

The poem delves into the theme of ego and the potential kindness of its deflation. The lines "Perhaps 'tis kindly done us / The Anguish and the loss" suggest that the reduction in scale is not merely a consequence of changed perspective but a deliberate act of mercy. The "wrenching for His Firmament" implies a forceful removal, perhaps of something that belonged to us or was integral to our identity. The subsequent lines, "To spare these Striding Spirits / Some Morning of Chagrin," offer a rationale: to prevent disappointment and disillusionment. The image of "Striding Spirits" suggests ambitious individuals, potentially ourselves, who are spared the humiliation of finding their monumental achievements reduced to the insignificant "Gnat's embrace." This suggests that our initial perceptions are often inflated, and the humbling process is a form of protection.

Giants Further On: A Symbol of Progress and Growth

The image of "Our Giants further on" is a particularly potent symbol. It can be interpreted as representing either past accomplishments or future potential. If it refers to past accomplishments, the poem suggests that even our greatest feats are destined to shrink in significance over time. If it refers to future potential, it implies that the deflation of our current perceptions is necessary for future growth and achievement. It could be that by allowing our ego to be diminished we are better equipped to achieve even more in the future. This interpretation also raises a question: Are we always the best judge of our own achievements, or is it better to let time and perspective guide our understanding of their true significance?

Conclusion: The Humble Truth of Transience

"We See Comparatively" is a poignant exploration of the shifting nature of perception and the often-painful process of recognizing the relative insignificance of what once seemed monumental. Through vivid imagery and a shift from awe to acceptance, Dickinson reveals a profound understanding of the human ego and the kindness inherent in its occasional deflation. The poem ultimately suggests that the transience of our perceptions and the humbling process of diminishing grandeur are essential components of growth and a more nuanced understanding of our place in the world.